Home›Blog›Sports Science›Strong in Both Legs, Short on One Side: What Strength Tests Can't See
Sports Science

Strong in Both Legs, Short on One Side: What Strength Tests Can't See

MF
Mark Fisher
11 November 20268 min read
ShareXinf

Summary

My view in one line: if she ran symmetrically, whatever the reason for the asymmetry, strength, injury or technique, the loads we prescribe her would land right where the research says they should. She doesn't, so they don't. And none of her strength tests would have told us why.

In Measurable Power vs. Applied Power, Dean Benton told the story of a 17-year-old sprinter who is strong by any gym measure, but when she accelerates over the initial 4 steps the right leg does about twice the work of the other. Since then her coach and I have been going back and forth by email about what that actually means. This is where we've landed.

My view in one line: if she ran symmetrically, whatever the reason for the asymmetry, strength, injury or technique, the loads we prescribe her would land right where the research says they should. She doesn't, so they don't. And none of her strength tests would have told us why.

Three reasons a leg goes quiet

When one leg puts less into the ground than the other, there are really only three explanations.

  1. It's weaker. Less strength or power in that leg.
  2. It's hurt. It's carrying an injury, or is still coming back from one, and the athlete protects it.
  3. It's not being used well. The strength is there, but the running technique stops it getting to the ground at the right time and in the right direction.

Each of those needs a different test. That's the whole point of this article.

What strength tests are good at

Concentric squat jump and a standing double hop offer the best correlation to initial acceleration as a respective lab-based and field-based tests. They answer one question well: is each leg capable?

For our sprinter the answer is yes, both of them. Her back squat is 1.8 times body weight. In a standing double hop she covers 6.80 metres off either leg. No difference left to right.

But "capable" isn't the same as "used". The research has been saying this for a while. Chris Bishop and colleagues tested athletes on an isometric squat and two single-leg jumps, and the stronger leg often changed from one test to the next [1]. In a second study the size of the asymmetry held up between sessions, but which leg came out ahead often didn't, even on the same test [2]. Exell and colleagues measured sprinters at top speed and found big force differences between legs, but no athlete was consistently dominant on one side, and jump asymmetry only partly matched what happened in the sprint [3]. Their conclusion was that imbalance is specific to the joint and the task.

Put simply, an asymmetry belongs to the task, not the athlete. If you want to know how evenly someone runs, you have to watch them run.

Even an injury can hide in a strength test

You'd think an injured leg would always show up. Often it doesn't.

Elizabeth Wellsandt's group followed 70 athletes after ACL injury [4]. At six months more than half passed the usual 90 percent symmetry mark on quad strength and every hop test. Only 29 percent were back to 90 percent of their own pre-injury level. The rest looked symmetrical because the good leg had gone backwards too. Kotsifaki and colleagues found athletes who'd been cleared to return to sport, and passed hop and strength symmetry, still had large knee deficits in a vertical jump, with the hamstrings quietly covering for the knee [5].

And on a single force plate, an isometric pull reads both legs as one number. There's no left or right to compare at all.

What the sled sees

A DynaSled pull is running. Arms, pelvis, timing, foot placement, all of it. The load cell reads the horizontal force coming through the tether on every stride, so a leg that isn't delivering shows up as a small peak between two big ones. Big, small, big, small, all the way down the track. You don't need software to see that pattern. It's in the trace.

That's where our sprinter's story turned. Her left strides averaged 342 newtons of peak force, her right 174. Nothing in her strength numbers predicted it.

She's not unusual, either. Brown, Cross and colleagues sprinted 30 uninjured rugby players on an instrumented treadmill [6]. Vertical force was almost even between legs, under 2 percent. Horizontal force was not: about 7 percent on average in acceleration, and up to 28 percent in some players. Healthy, strong athletes, with a horizontal force gap you'd never find in the gym.

And horizontal force is the one that matters. Jean-Benoît Morin and colleagues showed it isn't how much total force a sprinter produces that predicts performance, it's how well they point it forward [7, 8]. That's a technique quality. A strength test can't measure it.

The coach's eye, and a number

Her coach saw the cause on video. Her left arm is too passive, the right leg lands out in front, and every right contact starts with a block. A good coach with a good eye will pick that up.

But the eye is qualitative. It tells you something's wrong. It doesn't tell you how much it's costing, or whether this week's fix is working.

The sled does. If her right strides matched her left, her average stride would rise from about 258 newtons to 342. Put the other way, she's leaving somewhere between a quarter and a third of her horizontal force on the track, depending on which way you count it.

Putting a number on the fix (a theory, labelled as one)

This is where it gets interesting. Her load profile currently puts her best horizontal power at a 41 kilogram sled load, sled included. On a friction sled, the force needed to move at a given speed rises roughly in step with the load. So a third more force should mean about a third more load at the same speed: 41 kilograms becomes about 54 kilograms.

That's her coach's theory and my arithmetic. It's not a measurement. It assumes the gap we saw at 29 kilograms holds at 41, and it says nothing yet about her free sprint times. But it's a testable prediction, and the AUT work behind sled profiling gives us the tool to test it: for a given athlete, sled load and velocity sit on a straight line [9, 10]. If she evens up, that line should move, and we'll see by how much.

Testing is training is testing

Her coach's phrase, and it's the right one. She isn't tested once a quarter on a separate battery. She trains on the sled, so every training rep is also a test. The coach works on the left arm and the right foot placement, and watches the right-side peaks come up, or not, week by week.

That's the difference between finding a problem and fixing one. Without a tool like this in training, most coaches would have no idea why their athlete is slower than they should be. They'd see a strong kid with good jump numbers and keep loading the bar.

Is it magic dust?

I called it that in an email to her coach, and I'll stand by the feeling if not the words. There's nothing magic about it. It's measuring the thing you actually care about, horizontal force while running, instead of a proxy for it.

It's one athlete and one run so far, and a sled pull isn't a free sprint. We'll retest as her technique changes and publish what we find, whichever way it goes.

Dean Benton and I will talk this through in our next fireside chat on Sprint Mechanics.

Compiled by the Swift Performance team with AI assistance, edited by Mark Fisher.

References

  1. Bishop C, Lake J, Loturco I, Papadopoulos K, Turner A, Read P (2021). Interlimb asymmetries: the need for an individual approach to data analysis. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 35(3), 695-701. doi:10.1519/JSC.0000000000002729
  2. Bishop C, Read P, Chavda S, Jarvis P, Turner A (2019). Using unilateral strength, power and reactive strength tests to detect the magnitude and direction of asymmetry: a test-retest design. Sports, 7(3), 58. doi:10.3390/sports7030058
  3. Exell T, Irwin G, Gittoes M, Kerwin D (2017). Strength and performance asymmetry during maximal velocity sprint running. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports, 27(11), 1273-1282. doi:10.1111/sms.12759
  4. Wellsandt E, Failla MJ, Snyder-Mackler L (2017). Limb symmetry indexes can overestimate knee function after anterior cruciate ligament injury. Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy, 47(5), 334-338. doi:10.2519/jospt.2017.7285
  5. Kotsifaki A, Van Rossom S, Whiteley R, Korakakis V, Bahr R, Sideris V, Jonkers I (2022). Single leg vertical jump performance identifies knee function deficits at return to sport after ACL reconstruction in male athletes. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 56(9), 490-498. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2021-104692
  6. Brown S, Cross M, Girard O, Brocherie F, Samozino P, Morin J-B (2017). Kinetic sprint asymmetries on a non-motorised treadmill in rugby union athletes. International Journal of Sports Medicine, 38(13), 1017-1022. doi:10.1055/s-0043-117607
  7. Morin JB, Edouard P, Samozino P (2011). Technical ability of force application as a determinant factor of sprint performance. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 43(9), 1680-1688. doi:10.1249/MSS.0b013e318216ea37
  8. Morin JB, Bourdin M, Edouard P, Peyrot N, Samozino P, Lacour JR (2012). Mechanical determinants of 100-m sprint running performance. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 112(11), 3921-3930. doi:10.1007/s00421-012-2379-8
  9. Cross MR, Brughelli M, Samozino P, Brown SR, Morin JB (2017). Optimal loading for maximizing power during sled-resisted sprinting. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 12(8), 1069-1077. doi:10.1123/ijspp.2016-0362
  10. Cahill MJ, Oliver JL, Cronin JB, Clark KP, Cross MR, Lloyd RS (2019). Sled-pull load-velocity profiling and implications for sprint training prescription in young male athletes. Sports, 7(5), 119. doi:10.3390/sports7050119
MF

Mark Fisher

More from Sports Science